| Production | Played by | Opening Night |
|---|---|---|
| A Nativity Play 1911 (Abbey) | Goodwin, P | Thursday, 30 November 1911 |
| A Nativity Play 1912 (Abbey) | Goodwin, P | Thursday, 4 January 1912 |
| A Nativity Play 1927 (Abbey) | Wright, Udolphus | Monday, 26 December 1927 |
| A Nativity Play 1932 (Abbey) | Linnane, Joseph | Monday, 26 December 1932 |
