| Production | Played by | Opening Night |
|---|---|---|
| Thomas Muskerry 1910 (Abbey) | Harford, F. H. | Thursday, 5 May 1910 |
| Thomas Muskerry 1910 (Abbey) | Jameson, R. V. | Thursday, 13 October 1910 |
| Thomas Muskerry 1911 (Abbey) | Harford, Fred J. | Thursday, 9 March 1911 |
| Thomas Muskerry 1911 (Abbey) | Harford, Fred J. | Thursday, 9 March 1911 |
| Thomas Muskerry 1912 (Abbey) | Harford, Fred J. | Thursday, 31 October 1912 |
| Thomas Muskerry 1918 (Abbey) | Harford, Fred J. | Tuesday, 9 April 1918 |
| Thomas Muskerry 1926 (Abbey) | Nolan, Peter | Tuesday, 5 October 1926 |
| Thomas Muskerry 1936 (Abbey) | Wright, Udolphus | Tuesday, 4 August 1936 |
| Thomas Muskerry 1964 (Abbey) | Mc Darby, John | Monday, 19 October 1964 |
