| Production | Played by | Opening Night |
|---|---|---|
| Fanny's First Play 1925 (Abbey) | Carolan, P. J. | Tuesday, 21 April 1925 |
| Fanny's First Play 1925 (Abbey) | Carolan, P. J. | Tuesday, 6 October 1925 |
| Fanny's First Play 1926 (Abbey) | Carolan, P. J. | Monday, 18 January 1926 |
| Fanny's First Play 1926 (Abbey) | Carolan, P. J. | Monday, 19 April 1926 |
| Fanny's First Play 1926 (Tour) | Carolan, P. J. | Monday, 24 May 1926 |
| Fanny's First Play 1927 (Abbey) | Carolan, P. J. | Monday, 9 May 1927 |
| Fanny's First Play 1927 (Abbey) | Carolan, P. J. | Monday, 3 October 1927 |
| Fanny's First Play 1928 (Abbey) | Carolan, P. J. | Monday, 16 July 1928 |
| Fanny's First Play 1929 (Abbey) | Carolan, P. J. | Tuesday, 14 May 1929 |
| Fanny's First Play 1931 (Abbey) | Hayden, Christine | Monday, 21 September 1931 |
| Fanny's First Play 1936 (Abbey) | O'Gorman, William | Monday, 2 November 1936 |
| Fanny's First Play 1938 (Abbey) | O'Gorman, William | Monday, 14 February 1938 |
