| Production | Played by | Opening Night |
|---|---|---|
| The Shadowy Waters 1906 (Abbey) | Fay, Frank J | Saturday, 8 December 1906 |
| The Shadowy Waters 1923 (Abbey) | Shields, Arthur | Thursday, 15 March 1923 |
| The Shadowy Waters 1936 (Abbey) | Shields, Arthur | Monday, 18 May 1936 |
| The Shadowy Waters 1991 (Peacock) | Rocks, Sean | Tuesday, 27 August 1991 |
| The Shadowy Waters 1991 (Peacock) | Flood, Gary | Tuesday, 27 August 1991 |
