| Production | Played by | Opening Night |
|---|---|---|
| The Lost Leader 1918 (Abbey) | Fitzgerald, Barry | Tuesday, 19 February 1918 |
| The Lost Leader 1918 (Abbey) | McDonnell, P. J. | Tuesday, 19 February 1918 |
| The Lost Leader 1918 (Abbey) | McDonnell, P. J. | Wednesday, 3 April 1918 |
| The Lost Leader 1918 (Abbey) | Fitzgerald, Barry | Wednesday, 3 April 1918 |
| The Lost Leader 1918 (Abbey) | Denvir, C.P. | Tuesday, 3 December 1918 |
| The Lost Leader 1918 (Abbey) | McDonnell, P. J. | Tuesday, 3 December 1918 |
| The Lost Leader 1920 (Abbey) | Quinn, Tony | Thursday, 15 April 1920 |
| The Lost Leader 1920 (Abbey) | McDonnell, P. J. | Thursday, 15 April 1920 |
| The Lost Leader 1937 (Abbey) | Keegan, Malachi | Monday, 30 August 1937 |
| The Lost Leader 1937 (Abbey) | Barror, Cecil | Monday, 30 August 1937 |
